OUR STORY

The Toy Pit is Indianapolis’ premier toy store for collectors, families, and pop culture fans. We buy, sell, and trade collectibles, action figures, Funko Pops, blind boxes, vintage toys, video games, plush, and nostalgia from the 1970s to today.

​

Founded in 2009 in Fort Wayne, The Toy Pit began with one simple idea — to create a space where toy collectors could connect, share their passion, and rediscover the joy of collecting. In 2014, we moved to Indianapolis, and the city quickly became home to our growing community of collectors.

​

Now located down the street from the Indiana State Fairgrounds at 38th and College Avenue, The Toy Pit features a 13,000-square-foot showroom packed wall to wall with treasures. It’s become a destination for toy lovers across Indiana, offering something for everyone — from Star Wars, Marvel, DC, Transformers, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles to Godzilla, Dragon Ball, Hello Kitty, Barbie, Hot Toys, and vintage video games.

​

We also carry one of Indianapolis’ best selections of blind boxes and mystery collectibles from brands like Pop Mart, Sonny Angel, Tokidoki, Sanrio, and more — perfect for collectors who love the thrill of the surprise.

Our small team of lifelong collectors is passionate about helping you find that missing piece for your collection. Whether you’re buying, selling, or trading, we’re committed to offering friendly, fair service and authentic collectibles at competitive prices.

​

At The Toy Pit, collecting isn’t just about toys — it’s about nostalgia, connection, and keeping the excitement alive for the next generation of fans.