Indianapolis' ONLY Modern Antique Store! We specialize in all things collectibles vintage and modern, loose or in package! Action Figures, Records, T-Shirts, and more.


We are buying, selling and trading Tuesday-Friday 12pm - 6pm and Saturday 10:00 am- 6:00 pm. You can bring your collection into the shop during these hours. No appointment necessary! Stop by the shop today or give us a call at (317) 703-8697.

Scroll down the page to see the type of things we buy! We pay cash & trade!

Please, note that we GENERALLY do not buy comic books, sports cards, game cards, fast food toys, pez, beanie babies, or baby dolls but we do make exceptions occasionally.


We Buy, Sell & Trade All Things Vintage & Modern Pop Culture Collectibles!

Action Figures, Records, Video Games , and More!

  • Modern & Vintage Action Figures

  • Rock & Roll Records

  • Hip Hop Records

  • Vintage Pop Culture T-Shirts (70s-90s)

  • Star Wars

  • Pokemon

  • Barbie

  • GI JOE

  • Transformers

  • WWE & WWF Action Figures/T-Shirts

  • Vintage Sports Jerseys (70s-90s)

  • He-Man (Masters of The Universe)

  • Thundercats

  • Hot Wheels

  • Horror Collectibles

  • Funko Pops

  • Jurassic Park

  • Dragon Ball Z

  • Anime Collectibles

  • Hot Toys & Sideshow Collectibles

  • LEGO

  • Marvel

  • DC Comics

  • Music Memorabilia (T-Shirts, Posters, etc)

  • Vintage Video Games

  • Nintendo Collectibles

  • Disney

  • Select Comics and Graphic Novels

  • Mezco One:12

  • NECA

  • Mego

  • Godzilla

  • Power Rangers

  • Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

  • My Little Pony

  • Rainbow Brite

  • AND MORE!!!


© 2020 The Toy Pit. All rights reserved.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter