© Copyright 2017 The Toy Pit. All rights reserved.

  • Facebook App Icon
  • Instagram Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon

Here at the Toy Pit we buy, sell, & trade a variety of toys, dolls, & collectibles. These include, but ARE not limited to:

  • Transformers

  • Star Wars

  • Marvel (Avengers, X-Men, Spider-man)

  • DC (Batman, Superman)

  • Video Games

  • Barbies

  • My Little Pony

  • Dolls

  • Anime

  • McFarlene

  • Children's Toys (Playskool, Disney)

  • Funko Pop!

  • Godzilla

  • Die Cast

  • Pok√©mon

  • Horror

  • Statues

  • Plush

  • Wrestling (WWE, RAW)

  • Vintage

  • He-Man

  • Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

  • Thundercats

  • Sports

  • Star Trek

  • Lego

  • Power Rangers

  • G.I. Joe

  • Hot Toys

  • Sideshow Collectibles

  • Prop Replicas

  • Hot Wheels

About Us

The Toy Pit is the best local shop for collectible items in the Midwest. We buy, sell, and trade all things toy-related in Indianapolis, Indiana! Our inventory includes both modern and vintage toys.


We offer a variety of toys for all of our customers, from kids looking for something fun to new and experienced collectors. Formerly known as Intergalactic Toys, The Toy Pit offers a collection to inspire nostaliga, excitement, and fun.


Our knowledgeable staff can help identify toys, determine value, find your kids' new favorite toys, or help you start your own collection.


You simply cannot go wrong with The Toy Pit.


Find us on social media